Current:Home > Markets'Hi, Doc!' DM'ing the doctor could cost you (or your insurance plan) -CapitalEdge
'Hi, Doc!' DM'ing the doctor could cost you (or your insurance plan)
Oliver James Montgomery View
Date:2025-04-07 06:13:15
If you wanted to talk with your doctor before the pandemic, you generally had to schedule an in-person appointment. But the sudden, rapid expansion of telehealth means patients generally can now text or email their health care providers.
"When you wanted to get a Zoom visit or an audio visit, you needed to sign up for the patient portal, and I think a lot of people became aware that they could message for the first time" during the pandemic, says A Jay Holmgren, a researcher in health care information technology at the University of California San Francisco.
Patients love that direct contact with their doctors — so much so their messages are overwhelming doctors' inboxes. Now, some patients are getting billed by hospitals or health systems for some responses to their message queries.
Holmgren tracked how doctors spent more time during the pandemic managing electronic health records. Even after lockdowns ended, doctors were fielding over 50% more patient messages than before, he notes in a research letter published in the JAMA. That compounded stress for doctors already dealing with a pandemic, then responding to emails after hours, essentially working for free.
"Physicians who receive a ton of portal messages tend to report being burned out, tend to report being more cynical about their job, tend to report that they are thinking about leaving clinical practice," Holmgren says.
Many hospitals and health systems, from Johns Hopkins to Houston Methodist and Cleveland Clinic to Veterans Affairs, now charge patients who receive clinical advice through messages. Such charges are generally covered by Medicare and Medicaid, as well as most private insurance, though patients may bear co-pays, ranging from $5 to $75, depending on the type of plan.
Holmgren says the goal of charging for these messages was both to reimburse doctors, and discourage patients from excessive emailing. In actuality, however, he says the new charges have not solved either of those problems. His research shows doctors only bill for a tiny fraction of messages — about 3%. And the move to charge for them did not cut down on email volume. The fees led to slight declines of about 2% in the number of messages.
"Uptake has not been super high amongst our clinician workforce," Holmgren says, in part because billing for messages itself is complex and time consuming. Plus, doctors don't want to alienate patients by charging them for communicating.
In short, there's still no business model to support the realities of how patients and providers now talk to each other.
But Caitlin Donovan, senior director of the nonprofit National Patient Advocate Foundation, says finding one is essential. She represents patients who are chronically ill, or live in rural areas.
"Over the last few years we've realized that telecommunications is a health issue," Donovan says, adding that the ability to email doctors was transformative for many patients: "Sometimes patients don't have the energy to make that phone call, let alone come into the office." Plus there are people who live hours away from their doctors.
Donovan hopes the ability to email doctors can remain in place, without adding major costs to patients: "We're balancing both this need to rapidly expand access and to really entice providers to make it part of their practice, with trying to make sure that it is accessible and affordable for patients."
Eve Rittenberg, a primary care doctor and assistant professor at Harvard Medical School, also wants a system that supports the relationship between doctors and patients. "For me it's an incredible privilege that my patients share their fears and their worries and their questions with me and I can talk with them directly," she says.
But it also has to be sustainable, Rittenberg argues, and what's needed are better systems to sift through the constant influx of messages, filter out administrative tasks, and allow her to focus on responding only to clinical matters.
Part of the challenge is the compensation model itself, the most common of which is what's called fee-for-service. Health care companies bill for each and every service doctors and nurses perform. Rittenberg says she wants to see payment systems instead compensate doctors for providing overall care, regardless of whether that's in an office or over email.
She says that would give doctors and patients the flexibility to decide what works best for them. "Finding ways to make clear communications sustainable is really, really important," she says.
veryGood! (67)
Related
- Intellectuals vs. The Internet
- Wisconsin lawmakers consider regulating AI use in elections and as a way to reduce state workforce
- Kelly Osbourne Shares Why She Supports the Ozempic Trend
- Who should pay on the first date? Experts weigh in on the age-old question.
- Nearly half of US teens are online ‘constantly,’ Pew report finds
- House Intel chair's cryptic warning about serious national security threat prompts officials to urge calm
- From Sheryl Crow to Beyoncé: Here's what to know about the country music albums coming in 2024
- Gunfire at Chiefs’ Super Bowl celebration kills 1 and wounds nearly two-dozen, including children
- Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
- Student, 18, charged with plotting deadly shooting at his Southern California high school
Ranking
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- Bill would let Atlantic City casinos keep smoking with some more restrictions
- Beyoncé announces new album during 2024 Super Bowl after Verizon commercial hints at music drop
- Cyberattacks on hospitals are likely to increase, putting lives at risk, experts warn
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Arrests made in Cancun after 5 dismembered bodies found in taxi, 3 other victims dumped in shallow grave
- Yemen's Houthi rebels target carrier ship bound for Iran, their main supporter
- People's Choice Awards host Simu Liu promises to 'punch up': 'It's not about slandering'
Recommendation
Charges tied to China weigh on GM in Q4, but profit and revenue top expectations
Louisiana lawmaker proposes adding nitrogen gas and electrocution to the state’s execution methods
Pistons' Isaiah Stewart arrested, facing suspension after punching Suns' Drew Eubanks
A Kentucky lawmaker pushes to limit pardon powers in response to a former governor’s actions
Behind on your annual reading goal? Books under 200 pages to read before 2024 ends
All Chiefs players, coaches and staff safe after Super Bowl parade mass shooting
Casino and lottery proposal swiftly advances in the Alabama Legislature
12 Epstein accusers sue the FBI for allegedly failing to protect them